Statement by GLAAD President on the Rev. Robinson’s Participation in Inauguration
January 13, 2009
GLAAD’s President, Neil G. Giuliano, made a statement about the selection of the Rt. Reverend V. Gene Robinson to deliver the invocation at the opening celebration of the Presidential Inauguration:
President-elect Obama has made an excellent choice with the selection of Rev. Gene Robinson, and the broadcast will allow millions of people worldwide to participate in this historic event.
Rev. Robinson represents an incredible voice who has made great strides toward encouraging LGBT inclusion in faith communities. By featuring an openly gay faith leader, Obama is sending a strong message about the importance of truly inclusive faith voices that can move us away from exclusion and division and toward the common ground we share.
You can read the entire release here.
Continuing Media Coverage of Rick Warren Controversy
December 22, 2008
Media outlets continue their coverage of the controversy over Present-elect Barack Obama’s selection of Rick Warren to deliver the invocation at his inauguration. See the commentary and videos below:
December 19, 2008
CNN: American Morning – Warren Responds to Inauguration Outrage
12.19.08 06:15 am – CNN reports on anti-gay evangelical leader Rick Warren responding to the outcry over Obama inviting him to speak at the presidential inauguration. Warren: “Hopefully individuals passionately expressing opinions from the left and right will recognize that both of us have shown a model commitment to civility in America.”
December 18, 2008
Fox News: On the Record with Greta Van Susteren – Obama and The Base
12.18.08 10:42 pm – Greta Van Susteren and Rick Santorum share thoughts on Rick Warren speaking at the presidential inauguration. Santorum claims with such a move, Obama is saying, “‘Look, let me have the cover of being the moderate, and then I will go ahead and govern as a liberal.’”
Fox News: Hannity & Colmes – Barack Obama Defends Choosing Rick Warren to Deliver Inauguration
12.18.08 09:11 pm – Sean Hannity, Alan Colmes, Michael Steele, Maria Cardona and Erick Erickson talk about the Rick Warren controversy. Hannity claims, “Rick Warren – this is the kind of diversity and the kind of change Obama talked about. It’s not being ideological, it’s not having people only with whom you agree.”
MSNBC: The Rachel Maddow Show – Obama Selected Rick Warren to Give His Inauguration Invocation
12.18.08 09:00 pm – Rachel Maddow speaks out at length against Obama choosing Rick Warren to deliver the inaugural invocation. Maddow also interviews S.F. Mayor Gavin Newsom, who says he “disagree[s] with [Warren] vehemently” on LGBT issues, but that Warren’s selection can be “an opportunity, if we make it one.”
CNN: Campbell Brown: No Bias, No Bull – Inauguration Prayer Fight
12.18.08 08:26 pm – HRC’s Joe Solmonese on Rick Warren: “[I]n this moment, a symbolically important moment, when the eyes of the world are on this country and on this transitional moment, it would seem to me that there would be someone that president-elect Obama could pick to usher in a new day in America.”
Fox News: The O’Reilly Factor – Battle with the Base
12.18.08 08:21 pm – Truth Wins Out’s Wayne Besen and pastor (and Rick Warren’s friend) Robert Jeffress share their opinions on the Rick Warren controversy. Besen: “[L]et’s stop pretending that Rick Warren is a moderate. He’s masquerading as a moderate. This olive branch to evangelicals is more like poison ivy to [the LGBT community].”
MSNBC: Hardball with Chris Matthews – Obama Chooses Evangelical Pastor Rick Warren to Deliver Inaguration Invocation
12.18.08 07:43 pm – Chris Matthews, HRC’s Joe Solmonese and BeliefNet.com’s Steven Waldman debate the subject of Rick Warren’s inaugural invocation. Solmonese asserts that Obama’s selection of Warren is “an insensitive and politically shortsighted act,” while Waldman claims Obama is “trying to reach out to moderate evangelicals.”
PBS: NewsHour with Jim Lehrer – Insulting or Inclusive?
12.18.08 06:39 pm – Harry Knox, director of the religion and faith program at the Human Rights Campaign, and Michael Cromartie, vice president of the Ethics and Public Policy Center, offer opposing viewpoints on the issue of Rick Warren delivering the invocation at Obama’s inauguration.
MSNBC: 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue with David Gregory – Inaugural Invocation Uproar
12.18.08 06:37 pm – FRC’s Peter Sprigg and PFAW’s Kathryn Kolbert debate Obama’s selection of the anti-gay Rick Warren as an inaugural speaker. Kolbert says Warren is a “divisive” choice, while Sprigg claims Obama “wanted to reach out across some of these lines of division.”
CNN: The Situation Room – Gays to Obama: We Feel Disrespected
12.18.08 06:37 pm – HRC’s Harry Knox on Rick Warren at Obama’s inauguration: “It’s really very sad for us because we worked very hard for Senator Obama’s election – and now president-elect. And for us to not be respected by his choices in this case is really very disappointing to us.”
NBC: NBC Nightly News with Brian Williams – Politics & Prayer
12.18.08 06:28 pm – NBC’s Savannah Guthrie reports on LGBT equality advocates’ outcry over Rick Warren’s inauguration speech. HRC’s Harry Knox: “By making this pick, the president-elect really sent a message to me and to my community that we don’t matter as much to him as people who didn’t even vote for him.”
Fox News: Special Report with Brit Hume – Prayer Problems
12.18.08 06:16 pm – Brit Hume reports on reactions from the LGBT community and its supporters to Rick Warren speaking at President-elect Obama’s inauguration.
CNN: CNN Newsroom – Left Miffed at Obama
12.18.08 03:22 pm – CNN’s Rick Sanchez discusses the Rick Warren controversy with Firedoglake.com’s Jane Hamsher. Hamsher: “If [Obama} really wants to preach inclusiveness, then why not have somebody up there, a pastor who represents inclusiveness, and isn’t trying to build his political power by alienating and victimizing people who are gay?”
WSJ.com: Rick Warren
12.18.08 01:05 pm – The Wall Street Journal’s Adam Najberg discusses the controversy over Rick Warren’s anti-gay views and provides excerpt from an interview between Warren and BeliefNet.com’s Steve Waldman in which Warren made strong anti-gay statements.
CNN: American Morning – Obama Outrage over Rick Warren
12.18.08 07:04 am – Hilary Rosen on Rick Warren at Obama’s inauguration: “I think Rick Warren loses his moral authority when he, you know, is completely hypocritical about the way he deals with the issue of gays and lesbians and equality.”
More Media Coverage of Rick Warren Inaugural Controversy
December 19, 2008
MSNBC: MSNBC News Live – Rick Warren & The Inauguration
12.18.08 04:43 pm – PFAW’s Kathryn Kolbert, The American Prospect’s Ezra Klein, and Townhall.com’s Amanda Carpenter debate Obama’s selection of Rick Warren as an inaugural speaker. Kolbert: “We’re disappointed with the choice of pastor Warren primarily because he is opposed to many of the key constituents of the Obama electorate.”
MSNBC: MSNBC News Live – Rick Warren Invocation
12.18.08 01:59 pm – NBC News correspondent Chuck Todd says Obama’s decision to have pastor Rick Warren give the invocation at his inauguration is “almost like a final straw in what has been a very tense relationship between major gay Democratic power players and the Obama world. ”
MSNBC: MSNBC News Live – Ann Curry & Rev. Warren
12.18.08 12:20 pm – Dateline co-host Ann Curry talks about her interview with Rick Warren. Curry claims that Warren was “worried” that if Prop. 8 failed, “it would prevent him from getting up on the pulpit and speaking out against same-sex marriage,” even though the Calif. marriage decision had nothing to do with clergy.
ABC: The View – Elisabeth Hasselback on Rick Warren
12.18.08 11:17 am – The hosts of The View debate Rick Warren giving the invocation at Obama’s inauguration. Elisabeth Hasselback claims Rick Warren “is a great choice,” saying, “potentially maybe what President-elect Obama is trying to do is diminish the sort of negative cast that’s on Christian evangelicals.”
President-Elect Obama’s Troubling Inaugural Choice
December 18, 2008
Across the nation, LGBT people and progressives gasped as they read the headlines that President-elect Obama selected the Rev. Rick Warren to give the prayer of invocation at his inauguration. Obama’s hopeful statements of support for the LGBT community made the invitation to Warren that much more shocking. Bloggers and our collected media clips show that Warren has a long history of using his platform to perpetuate anti-gay stances.
Box Turtle states:
“Rick Warren claims he’s not a homophobe because he has “many gay friends” and has “eaten dinner in gay homes.” And yet, he still believes that his friends’ relationships are no different morally from child rape, incest or polygamy.
As the pastor of Saddleback mega-church (the fourth-largest church in the United States) he and his wife spent millions on global HIV/AIDS ministries. Conservatives criticize him for taking such a “liberal” stance on the HIV/AIDS issue, but he continues to equate same-sex marriage with incest and polygamy.
On Father’s Day this year, Warren met was persuaded to meet with the gay-affirming organization Soulforce, where he argued that gay people had to be celibate if they want to serve the church.
Saddleback Church drew global media attention as the venue for a presidential debate on values, which Warren followed up by using his media influence to speak against marriage for same-sex marriage. He was instrumental in building support for the passage of Proposition 8, which banned marriage for gay couples.
Today, President-elect Obama responded at a live press conference with carefully crafted talking points by saying that Warren had invited him to Saddleback in spite of their differing views on many topics and now he has invited Warren to be part of America’s “noisy conversation” of divergent opinions. Obama pointed to the Rev. Joseph E. Lowery as the minister who will give the benediction and has vastly different view on gay issues.
Recently, Warren said in an interview over at Beliefnet that he believes in full equality:
Beliefnet: Do you support civil unions or domestic partnerships?
Warren: I don’t know if I’d use the term there but I support full equal rights for everybody in America. I don’t believe we should have unequal rights depending on particular lifestyles so I fully support equal rights.
Beliefnet: What about partnership benefits in terms of insurance or hospital visitation?
Warren: You know, not a problem with me.
GLAAD has already urged the media ask incisive questions about what equality means in relation to employment, housing and protection from hate crimes. We challenge them to hold both Rick Warren and President-Elect Obama accountable and clarify what “equality” truly means to them.
Rick Warren Media Coverage Update
December 18, 2008
More media outlets are covering the growing controversy over Present-elect Barack Obama’s decision to select Rick Warren to deliver the invocation at his inauguration. See the commentary and videos below:
December 18, 2008
MSNBC: MSNBC News Live – Rick Warren Controversy
12.18.08 11:27 am – Newsweek’s Jonathan Alter analyzes Obama’s response to a reporter’s question on why he asked Rick Warren to speak at his inauguration. Alter: “What [Obama is] saying to gay rights activists is, ‘Look, the era of interest group politics leading around the Democratic party by the nose is over.’”
MSNBC: MSNBC News Live – President-elect Obama on Rick Warren
12.18.08 11:14 am – President-elect Obama discusses why he invited pastor Rick Warren to speak at his inauguration despite Warren holding views on social issues such as LGBT equality at odds with Obama’s own: “We’re not going to agree on every single issue. But what we have to do is be able to create an atmosphere where we can disagree without being disagreeable [...]”
CNN: American Morning – Inauguration Outrage
12.18.08 06:05 am – CNN reports on the outcry over President-elect Obama inviting pastor Rick Warren to speak at his inauguration. LGBT equality advocates are upset over the choice because of various anti-gay statements Warren has made in the past.
CNN: American Morning – Obama Outrage over Rick Warren
12.18.08 07:04 am – Hilary Rosen on Rick Warren at Obama’s inauguration: “I think Rick Warren loses his moral authority when he, you know, is completely hypocritical about the way he deals with the issue of gays and lesbians and equality.”
December 17, 2008
CNN: Anderson Cooper 360 – Digging Deeper: Inauguration Controversy
12.17.08 11:08 pm – Hilary Rosen, Robert Zimmerman and Roland Martin weigh in on Rick Warren giving the invocation at Obama’s inauguration. Rosen: “This is not a policy difference. This is not even about gay marriage. This is about the way that Pastor Warren has used homosexuality as a weapon [...]”
MSNBC: The Rachel Maddow Show – Lineup Announced for Obama’s Inauguration
12.17.08 09:52 pm – Rachel Maddow and Kent Jones discuss Rick Warren speaking at Obama’s inauguration. Jones sarcastically comments, “Apparently, in his invocation, Dr. Warren will be asking God not only to bless America but also to make it a lot less gay. They couldn’t get someone else? Come on.”
CNN: The Situation Room – Obama’s Choice Questioned
12.17.08 06:39 pm – In reference to the controversy over Rick Warren speaking at Obama’s inauguration, The Weekly Standard’s Stephen Hayes claims that it’s “not unhelpful…”
Past Media Coverage of Rick Warren
December 18, 2008
We’ve gone through and pulled some video from our archives on the past media coverage of Rick Warren. Check out the commentary and video below.
You can also view our YouTube playlist that GLAAD will be updating here: : http://www.youtube.com/view_play_list?p=3719D1D6EADA54BE
November 11, 2008
Comedy Central: The Colbert Report – Dan Savage
11.11.08 10:15 pm – Steven Colbert jokingly talks about Prop. 8 protests in front of Rick Warren’s Saddleback Church, and interviews Dan Savage on the suggested connection between Prop. 8 and black voters’ support.
Fox News: Hannity & Colmes – Rick Warren: Controversy Continues Over Prop. 8 in California
11.11.08 09:31 pm – Saddleback Church Pastor Rick Warren addresses a question about a gay member of his congregation being conflicted over his support of Prop. 8: “I just am opposed to redefining marriage. For five thousand years that term, ‘marriage,’ has represented a man and a woman.”
November 10, 2008
Fox News: The O’Reilly Factor – Culture Warrior: Prop. 8 Protests at Rick Warren’s Church
11.10.08 09:54 pm – Bill O’Reilly denounces Prop. 8 protests in front of Rick Warren’s church: “My problem here is that they’re directing their ire toward the wrong target. To go after a church, which is a private institution, they’re preaching based on biblical teachings. And there are biblical admonitions against homosexuality.”
January 2, 2008
Comedy Central: The Colbert Report – Rick Warren
December 20, 2007
Fox News: Hannity & Colmes – Warrens Address AIDS
12.20.07 09:00 pm – Pastor Rick and Kay Warren talk about their work with AIDS and Kay says, “I thought it was a gay disease. And for me I thought that meant I didn’t have to care. And I was so wrong.”
December 14, 2007
ABC: Nightline – Kay Warren on AIDS
12.14.07 11:42 pm – Kay Warren, wife of pastor Rick Warren, admits she did not respond to the AIDS crisis immediately because it “was tied with homosexuality,” but now says all people with HIV/AIDS should be treated with compassion.
April 6, 2007
CNN: What Would Jesus Really Do? – Pastor Rick Warren on Gays and AIDS
04.06.07 08:31 pm – Pastor Rick Warren says he does not agree with his “gay friends” on every issue, but that he can still work with them on issues like HIV/AIDS; says he can usually find common ground.
December 1, 2006
MSNBC: Tucker – Evangelicals Against Obama?
12.01.06 04:12 pm – Pastor Rick Warren talks about bringing together politicians on HIV/AIDS despite their other political views; Warren briefly mentions Ted Haggard and the the extreme right on LGBT issues.
April 19, 2006
CNN: CNN Saturday Night – Battling AIDS
08.19.06 10:13 pm – Purpose Driven Life author Pastor Rick Warren and his wife say AIDS is not a “gay disease” and that Christians should help people even if it was.
December 2, 2005
CNN: Larry King Live – Rick Warren on Gay People and AIDS
12.02.05 09:01 pm – Rick Warren, pastor and author of The Purpose-Driven Life, talks about churches fighting AIDS and why people are gay or lesbian.
December 1, 2005
ABC: ABC World News with Charles Gibson – Evangelicals Start AIDS Fight
12.01.05 06:30 pm – Evangelical Rick Warren talks about his new push to fight AIDS in America; says church has ignored AIDS in the past because it was seen as a gay issue.
GLAAD Calls on Media to Examine Rick Warren’s History of Anti-Gay Rhetoric
December 18, 2008
GLAAD released a statement today about President-elect Barack Obama’s selection of Rick Warren to deliver the invocation at his inauguration.
From GLAAD President Neil G. Giuliano:
The inauguration of a new President is a day when Americans should be brought together, to signal a new beginning for our country. It is therefore deeply troubling that the President-elect has selected someone whose defamatory and damaging anti-gay statements and views, including linking marriage for committed same-sex couples to incest and pedophilia, clearly divide rather than unite Americans. Media outlets have a responsibility to scrutinize Rick Warren’s history of using his powerful platform to advance anti-gay rhetoric and prevent loving couples from being able to take care of and be responsible for one another.
Eye on the Media – Post-Election LGBT & Prop 8 Coverage
November 17, 2008
On Friday, GLAAD released a document entitled “Eye on the Media” which looks at post-election media coverage of LGBT issues and California’s proposition 8. From the document:
Los Angeles, CA – The Gay & Lesbian Alliance Against Defamation (GLAAD) today provided recommendations to help media outlets provide fair, accurate and inclusive coverage of the aftermath of Prop 8 in California and the rallies being organized at the grassroots level throughout the United States.
Since the Nov. 4 vote on anti-gay ballot measures in California, Arizona, Florida and Arkansas, GLAAD has been working with print and broadcast journalists in national, regional and local markets on their coverage of these ballot measures and local community responses. Following our conversations with journalists and community leaders, these recommendations are designed to address continuing misinformation about these issues and promote media coverage that is fair, accurate and inclusive.
You can read all about the various misinformation and the recommendations to journalist by clicking here. Make sure to share with your friends and family!
New York Times Documents Transgender Disenfranchisement
November 17, 2008
We had posted earlier on how transgender people were being alluded to, but not directly mentioned, in national media coverage on voter disenfranchisement. Well, on Election Day, The New York Times spotlighted this often-disenfranchised and overlooked voting bloc on their blog The City Room.
The post, ”Fighting for the rights of Transgender Voters” by Corey Kilgannon, marked the first mainstream media mention of the disenfranchisement often experienced by transgender voters.
Some transgender advocates, such as Helen Boyd, noted that the piece focused more on the appearances of the voters than on the discrimination they faced. However, the article was promoted on the web site of the Transgender Legal Defense and Education Fund where they stated:
“Articles like this, which inform the public about the day-to-day difficulties that transgender people face, have the power to change hearts and minds.”
The Rev. Louis Braxton, director of Carmen’s Place, a group home for gay teenagers and young adults in Astoria, Queens, talks about the recent incident involving teenagers who attacked him. (Photo: Ruby Washington/The New York Times)
Kilgannon interviewed Michael Silverman, Executive Director of the Transgender Legal Defense and Education Fund on the issues facing the “ten of thousands” of transgender New Yorkers at the polls. He also interviewed the Director of Carmen’s Place, Father Louis Braxton, and transgender voter Michelle Carver.
From an earlier initiative to organize transgender voters as a visible political bloc to this latest article, transgender voters have seen themselves reflected in media coverage more than ever during this election cycle. Kudos to The New York Times for covering this important issue.
Record-Breaking Number of LGBT Candidates Elected
November 14, 2008
While the LGBT community and its allies are disheartened by ballot results in Arkansas, Arizona, California and Florida, a look at this election’s nationwide results of elected LGBT officials give us much to be hopeful about.
In a record-breaking election, more than 70 percent of the openly lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender candidates running for public offices across the country were elected on Tuesday. The Gay & Lesbian Victory Fund endorsed a total of 111 candidates in this cycle.
Chuck Wolfe, President and CEO of the Victory Fund, released the following statement:
“This was a watershed election. Our government became more representative and our democracy became stronger. As we near the 30th anniversary of the death of Harvey Milk, it’s enormously gratifying to see his dream realized in so many brave men and women heeding the call to run for office, and doing so openly, honestly and unafraid”
Among the winners:
- Jared Polis of Colorado became the first openly gay man elected to the U.S. Congress as a non-incumbent. Polis joins Rep. Barney Frank and Rep. Tammy Baldwin, both reelected, as the only openly LGBT Members of Congress.
- Kate Brown of Oregon became the first openly LGBT Secretary of State in the U.S.
- Jason Bartlett of Connecticut became the second openly gay African-American state legislator in the nation as he was reelected to the Connecticut State House.
- John Perez became the first openly gay person of color elected to the California Assembly.
- Kevin Beckner won a seat on the Hillsborough County Commission in Florida as the first openly gay man to be elected in the county.
- Rebecca Kaplan became the first openly gay woman elected to the Oakland, California City Council.
You can see a full list of LGBT candidates and winners by visiting: http://www.victoryfund.org/election_scorecard.
Fox News: America’s Election Headquarters – Referendums
November 5, 2008
11.05.08 04:48 am – As part of a Fox News panel, John Fund of the The Wall Street Journal claims Calif.’s Prop. 8 has passed despite final results on the anti-gay initiative not yet being reported.
CNN: Election Night in America – Ballot Initiatives: Gay Marriage Ban Still Undecided
November 5, 2008
11.05.08 04:33 am – CNN’s Carol Costello talks about the Prop. 8 race in Calif. still being too close to call, and how both opponents and supporters of the anti-gay measure thought high voter turnout could help their campaigns.
Fox News: America’s Election Headquarters – Arizona Voters Approve Anti-Gay Amendment
November 5, 2008
11.05.08 03:16 am – Arizona voters approved Prop. 102, which will amend the state’s constitution to ban marriage for gay couples.
Election News Update – 2:47am
November 5, 2008
Associated Press: Record Turnout Expected as Californians Cast Votes on Key Initiatives
11.05.08 12:50 am - Though California voters came out in record numbers for Barack Obama, polls suggest a “virtual tossup” in the outcome of the Prop. 8 battle.
The Washington Post: EDITORIAL: Hate Crimes
11.05.08 12:44 am - The Washington Post calls FBI statistics that found a 5.5 percent increase in hate crimes based on sexual orientation “cause for concern,” saying, “offenses rooted in animus toward a victim’s real or perceived characteristics are especially pernicious.”
Hartford Courant (CT): Election Results
11.05.08 01:43 am - In Conn., 82 percent of voting precincts are now reporting that 60 percent of the state’s voters said “no” to Question 1.
Los Angeles Times: In Conservative Temecula and Murrieta, McCain and Prop. 8 Rule the Day
11.05.08 12:55 am - Despite most of Calif. voting Democratic in the presidential election, much of a traditionally Republican area of Riverside County seems to have voted for McCain and in favor of the anti-gay Prop. 8.
Associated Press (CA): Gay Marriage Leads Long List of Calif. Initiatives
11.04.08 10:00 pm - Among the 12 ballot initiatives Calif. voters will decide on this Election Day, Prop. 8 by far generated the most attention and the most expensive campaigns on both sides of the issue.
Associated Press (NC): Partisan Makeup of NC Supreme Court At Stake
11.04.08 09:55 pm - N.C. voters will decide on several state Supreme Court justices and Court of Appeals judges in tonight’s election, including choosing between openly gay Judge John Arrowood, who is seeking a full term, and his opponent, Bob Hunter.
CBS5.com [San Francisco] (CA): No On 8 Ad Denounced As ‘Religious Bigotry’
11.04.08 09:42 pm - Several Calif. religious leaders spoke out against the Courage Campaign TV ad dramatizing Mormon support of Prop. 8. The ad is not affiliated with the No on 8 campaign.
KCBS-2 (Los Angeles): Local News – Prop. 8
November 5, 2008
KCBS-2 interviews Sonja Eddings-Brown from the anti-gay Prop. 8 campaign, and checks in at No on 8’s election-night event in Los Angeles.
